Wednesday, January 14, 2009

A Rose from the Taliban

Great article about the talibanization of the Pakistan border and apparent efforts of Zardari et all to combat the growing power of militants. Article alleges that Baitullah Meshud and the Meshud tribe of North Waziristan is at the center of the Jihadist movement in Pakistan. the article was brought to my attention by the excellent blog TheCaptainsJournal a Marine blog that focuses on Tactics, Techniques and Procedures (TTP). With Obama set to commit more troops and the military searching for new supply routes the focus on tactics is going to be crucial. Its a subject covered in this post and which I hope to discuss further in the days ahead.

As the WPost articles makes clear, "...the incoming administration does not anticipate that the Iraq-like "surge" of forces will significantly change the direction of a conflict that has steadily deteriorated over the past seven years. Instead, Obama's national security team expects that the new deployments, which will nearly double the current U.S. force of 32,000 (alongside an equal number of non-U.S. NATO troops), will help buy enough time for the new administration to reappraise the entire Afghanistan war effort and develop a comprehensive new strategy for what Obama has called the "central front on terror."

Developing a strategy would help, but the next step will be adopting tactics necessary to achieve said strategic goals.

More discussions to come...

Monday, January 12, 2009

Taming the Russian Bear

Although Russia and Ukraine have apparently reached an agreement on pipeline and gas pricing, Russia's bellicose attitude in 2008 is sure to reverberate in 2009. Although they are facing substantial economic difficulty and will probably have the worst economic year of the BRIC country's Moscow shows few signs of toning down in the foreign policy realm. Selling fighter jets to Lebanon, sending its navy on diplomatic visits to Latin America and the Indian Ocean, and clamping down on domestic dissent, Russia's resurgence may be tested by the financial crisis, but economic hardship is something most Russians are accustomed to.

What should the U.S. do? Fundamentally, U.S. policy should be to "Europeanize" Russia. That is, to help it modernize its political and economic institutions by integrating it into the system of Western political cooperation and the global economy. They need to understand that 'democracy' is not necessarily the prereq for respect and investment, but the rule of law is. In Europe the U.S. should pursue a respectful and accommodating policy towards Russia and largely follow the lead of the Germans. Not pushing for quick NATO expansion.

In Asia, our policy towards Russia should be somewhat different. We should continue to push for the opening of Central Asia. Doing so will require mending fences with Iran, maintaining our commitment to Afghanistan, and preventing relations with Pakistan from collapsing completely. Finally, the U.S. needs to drive a wedge between Russia and the emerging powers of India and China. Traditionally strong Indo-Russian defense ties can be countered by offering India access to our own military technology as well as expanding bilateral trade and investment in non-defense areas (there is little India wants from Russia other than weapons or energy). As far as China is concerned, the U.S. has to prevent a Sino-Russian anti-hegemonic axis. Doing so will require paying greater respect to China and offering them a privileged position in global politics (good policy for other reasons too). Such a G-2 formulation will help preserve the differences that have existed since the Sino-Soviet split and U.S. recognition of China.

U.S. Russian relations are likely to remain contentious in some areas, but the U.S. can work to reduce Russia's leverage in Asia while working to tame and integrate the Bear into a more European framework. Russia must remain a regional power.

The Greatest Threat We Face

David Sanger's piece in the NYT Magazine about Pakistan and the security of its nuclear weapons is downright scary. There are several things however, that I think ought to be clarified. First, I think it is not very likely that Islamic terrorist (i.e. AQ) could seize Pakistani weapons. I suspect that the security of their stockpile is sufficient to prevent that. However, the threat is that were Pakistan's government to splinter or fail, that some faction in the military or intelligence could end up in possession of a few weapons. If this faction were sympathetic to the Islamist cause, the weapons could be passed to non-state actors or. Even if the faction in control of the weaponize were not sympathetic to Islamists, they could be less secure and more vulnerable to seizure.

The other threat is that a group like AQ would develop its own crude weapon. This would require possession of fissile material, the ability to enrich it, and the knowledge of how to trigger and weaponize it. Obtaining unenriched material would not be too difficult, but enriching it sufficiently would pose substantial challenges. If the group were to obtain enriched material or were to develop their own centrifuges and enrichment process they would have to develop method for triggering or detonating the weapon. This would require the knowledge and skills of someone who had worked on a nuclear weapons program. According to Sanger's article, there are about 2,000 people in Pakistan's programs with this "critical knowledge." If Islamists are able to infiltrate this group they could receive assistance in developing their own crude weapon.

In short, I am not sure I can stay in D.C. for too many more years as it seems like the possibility of a WMD attack in the U.S. in the next decade is not insubstantial. However, sadly, I suspect it is more likely to be an Indian city that would receive the first blow.