Monday, November 24, 2008

Rethinking U.S. Policy Towards Latin America? How about formulating a Latin America policy...?

Although the Bush Administration's foreign policy has been characterized by numerous failures one of the least often discussed has been the absence of a coherent Latin America (LA) policy. Other than keeping cozy with Uribe and Columbia, negotiating free trade agreements, denouncing Chavez and other insubordinate national leaders, has the Bush Administration actually developed a policy towards Latin America? At best our LA policy could be described as benign neglect.

Well, its transition time, and members of the "government in waiting" at various think tanks around town are vying for their place at the table (its time to dust off those policy proposals we didn't offer for the last few years cause we were golfing). The Brookings Institutions recently released a report "Re-Thinking U.S.-Latin American Relations: A Hemispheric Partnership for a Turbulent World"

Well, surprise surprise, the report calls for the new administration to put Latin America at the center (or at least on) its "foreign policy radar" (i.e. we understand that you sank virtually all our diplomatic and military resources into the sands of the Middle East for the last 8 years, but frankly the U.S. is a BIG country and we have the bandwidth to pursue a coherent policy in multiple regions of the world at the same time).

And while the Brookings report undoubtedly lays the groundwork for a more coherent Latin America policy than has been pursued under Bush, one also suspects that it does not fully account for the changes in the region that are likely to result from the global financial crisis (Cue Karen, this is your chance to expound on the trajectory of the region in the coming year).

Latin America is likely to be hard hit by the drying up of international credit, the crash in commodity prices, and slower export growth resulting form slower global growth. Yet some countries are undoubtedly better prepared to weather the crisis than others. Some like Brazil learned the lessons of the 1980s and 1990s. Others like Venezuela, which decided to retry price controls and a command economy (which is all good and well when oil is at $150/barrel but really becomes difficult when its at $40/ barrel) are likely to face some very difficult times.

U.S. engagement in the region is essential. There is a case to be made that Latin America is at a real turning point. Countries can either become nostalgic for their populist and authoritarian traditions or follow the example of leaders like Brazil and Chile who offer new models of development. The financial crisis may create a window of opportunity to arrest the Chavista drift in the region and give legitimacy to more cautious and pragmatic voices. The U.S. needs to arrest its own Latin America policy drift and foster an environment where those moderate voices can thrive. Having enough respect for the countries in the region to formulate coherent policies towards them is a good first step in that direction.

No comments:

Post a Comment