Tuesday, November 25, 2008

A Trade Worth Making...? What Did We Just Trade...?

This fascinating op-ed by a renowned Tibet scholar at Columbia University has potentially important implications (particularly for regional security in South Asia). According to the author, the British government recently reversed its position on support for Tibetan autonomy in exchange for Chinese cooperation in responding to the global financial crisis. While such a move may seem like a small belated gesture of little significance given China's firm grip on Tibet the implications of the new British policy could be much larger:


"Britain’s change of heart risks tearing up a historical record that frames the international order and could provide the basis for resolving China’s dispute with Tibet....But the decision has wider implications. India’s claim to a part of its northeast territories, for example, is largely based on the same agreements — notes exchanged during the Simla convention of 1914, which set the boundary between India and Tibet — that the British appear to have just discarded. That may seem minor to London, but it was over those same documents that a major war between India and China was fought in 1962, as well as a smaller conflict in 1987."


If Britain accedes to Chinese claims over Tibet, have they not also by implication nullified the Simla Accord and thus raised anew the legitimacy of the entire Sino-Indian border? Could this reversal of policy possibly have come at a worse time? Talks between the Dalai Lama and Beijing recently collapsed in acrimony. Just last weekend Tibetan exiles met in Dharmasala to discuss the future of their movement. Apparently many younger Tibetan exiles are even calling into question the efficacy of the Dalai Lama's non-violent "middle way." Could the timing or political message possibly have been a coincidence?

Perhaps. Or perhaps not. Perhaps Britain is signalling that at least on the issue of Tibet it is willing to recognize Beijing's territorial claims in exchange for China becoming a 'responsible stakeholder' in international institutions and the management of the international system?

Is this a worthy trade? Is it Britain's to make? What else might need to be offered in order to get Chinese 'buy in?' Without becoming alarmist, would this constitute appeasement?

No comments:

Post a Comment