Friday, December 19, 2008

Petraeus's Cautious Optimism

These days I see more to be cautious about than optimistic. But I have to hand it to him at least Petraeus doesn't make triumphalist comments like Rumsfeld and Cheney. He knows all too well the hard slog ahead.

With elections in both Iraq and Afghanistan in 2009 and the promise of a fresh Taliban offensive in the spring, conditions could easily deteriorate in the first half of next year on both fronts. In Iraq, a small uptick in violence has gone largely unnoticed, but as I suggested in a previous post, the situation is ripe for AQ meddling. Attacks designed to stoke sectarian tension could prevent the U.S. from redeploying as quickly as is now planned. Although the government showed its teeth in 2008 in Basra and Sadr City, it is still fragile. If Parliament is divided over a shoe thrower, imagine what kind of political deadlock could follow potentially controversial elections.

Right now, Obama's presidency essentially hinges on continued progress in Iraq in order to redeploy to Afghanistan and pay for domestic spending. I suspect there will be substantial setbacks to the withdrawal plan in 2009 making Iraq another campaign promise that is more difficult to deliver on than anticipated. Fortunately (or unfortunately, deficits apparently no longer matter, so stay in Iraq as long as you need, its good for the economy!)

No comments:

Post a Comment